ππππ
One Bad Apple premiered in April of 2024. It is the 4th movie in the Hannah Swensen Hallmark mystery series, but the 9th overall if we're including the Murder, She Baked series. All of these movies are from the same universe and have the same main characters, but the series was renamed after the first five movies.
In One Bad Apple, Hannah (Alison Sweeney) is teaching a baking class at the local college. During one of the sessions, some of her equipment explodes. It is ruled an accident, but when one of Hannah's colleagues is later found dead, our baker turned amateur sleuth suspects otherwise and she begins to investigate this mystery.
As usual, I really enjoyed this installment in the long-running cozy mystery series. It continues to be my favorite series on Hallmark with its light-hearted feel and fun mysteries. This installment brought back the scenes at the beginning and end of the movie where Hannah is baking and also doing a voiceover where she compares baking to real life. This is one of the elements of the original Murder, She Baked series that I loved, so I'm happy it was brought back.
I also once again enjoyed all of the main characters, although some things with them were different in One Bad Apple. They biggest change was that Cameron Mathison, who played Detective Mike Kingston and Hannah's love interest, is no longer filming Hallmark movies (at least not at the time of this writing). I won't give specific spoilers, but his character was written out the show and someone else is the new detective. I really missed not seeing Cameron Mathison, but I'm satisfied with the way they dealt with his departure.
New to the series is Victor Webster, who plays the prosecuting attorney, Chad. Hannah's and his lives intersect in this installment, so we will have to keep watching to see how their interactions unfold. It's likely he will become Hannah's new love interest, but I think it will be a very different kind of relationship than what Hannah had with Mike. I do appreciate that they are not rushing it.
Barbara Niven returned as Hannah's mother, Delores, but her role in this installment is very different. She is now a somewhat over-the-top private investigator. I loved her in this role. She added the best light-heartedness and comic relief. I'm interested in seeing her as a private investigator in future installments. I think we're in for some fun times ahead!
I have always enjoyed Gabriel Hogan as Norman and I'm so happy he was back in this movie sleuthing with Hannah. I love the way he supports and grounds her. Although Andrea, Hannah's sister, played by Lisa Durupt, didn't have a huge role, I'm glad they found a way for her to make an appearance. I also enjoyed seeing Michelle, Hannah's younger sister, played by Tess Atkins. I like the way the character of Michelle has evolved since she joined the cast a few movies ago.
As for the mystery element in this movie, I did figure out who the culprit was almost as soon as the character were introduced. However, this was completely based on a gut feeling, not on any clues. I was still curious to see how the mystery would unfold and if my guess would be correct. It was a fun mystery to untangle, complete with a suspenseful conclusion.
So, while this wasn't my favorite installment in the series, I'm still a fan. I'm glad they are not exactly like the books. That way if you see the movies, but haven't read the books yet, or vice versa, there won't be any spoilers. If you're expecting the books and movies to be the same, you will be met with disappointment, but if you view them as two different forms of entertainment, I think you will appreciate them for what they each are. And like the books, each movie in the series is a self-contained mystery. However, because of ongoing storylines, the movies are also best enjoyed in order, starting with
Murder, She Baked: A Chocolate Chip Cookie Mystery.