ππππ
A Classic Case of Murder, by Daryl Wood Gerber, is the third installment in her Literary Dining Mystery series. Each book is based on a different classic novel. This one is based on one of my favorites, A Christmas Carol, by Charles Dickens.
The series is set in the charming small town of Bramblewood, North Carolina. Personal chef and caterer, Allie Catt, combines her loves of food and fiction by hosting literary dining parties. In A Classic Case of Murder, her next event is taking place at the Amber Lantern, an inn recently opened by her best friend, Noeline. When a prized first edition of A Christmas Carol goes missing and someone is murdered, it isn't turning out to be a happy Christmas after all. With the prime suspect being a friend of Allie's and her best friend's business at risk, she puts on her sleuthing cap and sets out to solve this murder mystery.
I really loved the vibe of this book. The atmosphere of the era in which A Christmas Carol was written was perfectly captured. The vivid descriptions gave me all the warm, classic Christmas feels and awakened my senses.
Some of the characters' names and their personalities were reminiscent of those in A Christmas Carol. This added a nice touch, especially for fans of the original story. There were a lot of suspects to keep track of, but each had distinct names and personalities. It was also a delight to be reunited with the main recurring characters in the series. I appreciated a character list with brief descriptions of who they all were at the beginning of the book, which I sometimes referred to while reading.
Allie is a very likeable amateur sleuth. She cares about her loved ones and wants justice to be served. She's intelligent, friendly, and works well with her detective boyfriend. I also appreciate her focus on mental health. Our cozy mystery amateur sleuths experience a lot of trauma. It's refreshing to see someone who meets with a therapist even though she's overall happy with where she's at in life right now.
Darcy, the cat, appears throughout this series. I hope at some point Darcy becomes involved in solving a mystery, even if it's just one scene, but for now he's a purrfect cozy companion.
The setting had a classic cozy mystery feel to it. The inn was warm and quaint. It's a place I would love to stay for a little getaway, especially at Christmastime. As someone who is physically disabled, I appreciated the mentions of the inn having an elevator, although in one scene there were stairs described at the front entrance. I wasn't sure how I'd be able to get up those stairs. It didn't take away from my overall enjoyment of the story, but I like to imagine myself in the setting when I read a cozy. It's difficult to do that if the buildings are not accessible.
The mystery was solid. Allie's boyfriend is the detective and I loved how they informally worked together on this case. There were twists and turns, and plenty of suspects to keep me guessing until the end. Ultimately, I did not identify the whodunnit.
Besides the character list, there are a few other, what I call, extras, in this book. Each chapter begins with a quote from A Christmas Carol. Throughout A Classic Case of Murder, there are mentions of other books. I assure you, my TBR list has grown as a result of reading this book. If you enjoy recipes in cozies, you'll be glad to know there are several delicious-sounding ones at the end.
If you love book-themed mysteries, delicious food, and Christmas cozies, I highly recommend A Classic Case of Murder, by Daryl Wood Gerber. To see the character development, you can start from the beginning of the series with Murder on the Page. However, enough information is given without spoilers in A Classic Case of Murder that it can easily be read as a standalone. The digital format has already been released. The hardcover edition is set to be released on November 24, 2026.
Thank you to NetGalley and Kensington Publishing for providing me with an eARC of this book.







